Exploring progress towards the Welsh Government’s energy targets and their future evolution: insights from our latest Energy Generation in Wales report

Ellie Brundrett, project manager, Regen


In 2017, the Welsh Government set a target for Wales to meet the equivalent of 70% of its electricity demand from Welsh renewable electricity sources by 2030. That same year, Wales generated the equivalent of around 48% of its electricity demand from renewables, up from less than 20% just three years earlier. But since 2017 progress towards the 70% target has progressed slowly, despite the Welsh Government’s ambition, positive planning environment and developer ambition.


In 2021, the Welsh Government committed to consulting on their renewable energy targets, and commissioned Regen to gather evidence of future energy trends to inform the evolution of their targets in the future. This review of Wales' renewable energy targets consultation was published this week, with a headline proposal for the Welsh Government to set a target of meeting the equivalent of 100% of Welsh annual electricity consumption from renewable electricity sources by 2035.


The line of progress is never straight

This target is impacted by both electricity demand and generation, meaning that if electricity demand in Wales increases over time, then the absolute volume of electricity generated by renewables also needs to increase, to meet that 70% target.


Electricity consumption reduced markedly in 2020, from 14.7 TWh in 2019 to 13.8 TWh[1], likely caused by Covid-19 lockdowns. Despite 2020 seeing the lowest level of renewable deployment since 2010, this reduction in demand meant that progress towards Wales’ 70% target jumped from 51% in 2019 to 56% in 2020.


Figure 1: Growth in the percentage of electricity consumption from renewable sources in Wales


In 2021, we saw the beginning of a return to pre-pandemic energy use, with electricity demand increasing to 14 TWh[2]. Meanwhile, renewable generation only grew marginally between 2020 to 2021 – from an estimated 7.6 TWh to 7.7 TWh – which wasn’t enough to offset the growth in demand. Therefore, progress towards the Welsh Government’s 70% target stalled, with the 2021 figure of 55% slightly below that seen in 2020.


Figure 2: Wales’ annual renewable energy installation rate


While the marginal gains in renewable generation could be blamed on the impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic, recent trends suggest that there are more deep-rooted barriers to renewable energy deployment to blame: over the last five years, renewable electricity generation in Wales has only increased by 9%, compared to 140% in the preceding five years. Why is this the case, despite the Welsh Government setting ambitious targets and striving to create a positive policy environment?

  • Grid, grid, grid

    It is well recognised that securing grid capacity is a major barrier to successfully deploying renewables in Wales. A 2022 report from the House of Commons Welsh Affairs Committee exploring grid capacity in Wales stated that:

    Our report on Renewable Energy in Wales[3] concluded that developers of renewable energy were encountering problems with grid capacity and connecting to the electricity grid in Wales. Grid capacity in Wales is significantly constrained.

    They highlighted the risk of grid constraints impacting Wales’ ability to meet its decarbonisation targets, stating that grid infrastructure must be able to cope with the projected increase in demand for electricity, and even posited that:

    It would be inequitable for the UK to benefit from Wales’ renewable energy resources while Welsh communities were not adequately connected to the grid.

    The Welsh Government has recognised this challenge in its Future Energy Grids for Wales project, which aims to achieve a long-term approach and joint view, across all grid operators and other stakeholders, of the likely future energy needs across Wales to 2050. The project will decide on the steps to evolve networks to support Wales’ Net Zero Carbon ambition and the work needed to achieve this, drawing on the perspectives of a wide range of people across Wales.

  • Planning timelines

    At a national level, the Welsh Government has confirmed a commitment to renewable deployment and has striven to create a positive planning environment, with the publication of a key policy document in 2021 – the Future Wales National Development Framework, which reiterated strong support for onshore wind and identified a series of ‘Pre-Assessed Areas for Wind Energy’. Within these areas, which cover almost 281,000 hectares, there is now a presumption in favour of large scale energy developments, subject to meeting additional policy requirements around a number of areas, such as ecological and heritage sites and sustainable construction.


    Furthermore, in July 2022 the First Minister announced the introduction of a Bill on Infrastructure Consenting, which is intended to replace existing statutory regimes for the consenting of Welsh infrastructure projects, and reduce the number of authorisations required to consent to a project. This suggests that the Welsh Government is keen to simplify the process for developing major infrastructure projects.


    However, the Renewable Energy Planning Database (REPD)[4] which tracks the progress of UK renewable electricity projects over 150 kW through the planning system, shows that over 680 MW of renewable energy projects have been abandoned in Wales since 2001, and a further 2,400 MW are awaiting a planning decision (as of October 2022) – the majority of which is represented by 40 projects which have submitted applications in the past three years. While it is difficult to identify the main cause of projects being abandoned, the volume of projects awaiting a planning decision highlights how lengthy the planning process can be.

  • Money doesn’t grow on trees

    The ending of financial support mechanisms during the latter part of the 2010s has been a key factor in slowing deployment of many types of renewables which, when combined with rising installation costs in recent years, means that developing viable subsidy-free business cases for projects has been challenging. This has been further compounded in recent months by the current energy crisis, driving up inflation and further increasing the costs associated with construction.


    The Contracts for Difference (CfD) scheme is a well-established support mechanism for developing renewable projects. However, due to capacity limits imposed in the allocation rounds, only a fraction of renewable projects being developed are able to secure a CfD.


    As we discuss in our response to BEIS’  Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA) consultation[5], Regen has long supported the extension of the CfD scheme for variable renewable generation, calling for a much clearer long term strategy for renewable energy deployment and supporting the move to annual allocation rounds. This would send a positive signal to investors, allow developers to build their project portfolios, utilities to invest in grid infrastructure and supply chain companies to build the jobs, skills and capabilities needed to efficiently deliver net zero.

In recognition of these challenges faced by developers, in 2021 the Welsh Government undertook a Deep Dive[6] exercise to identify opportunities to significantly scale up renewable energy in Wales, and is working to address some of the most significant barriers to deployment as it implements its recommendations, including:

  • Setting up a joint working group to look at options for supporting new, flexible grid connections for renewables and energy storage solutions.

  • Undertaking a review of consenting and supporting evidence and advice, to ensure a timely and proportionate planning process.

  • Setting up a working group to review options for how procurement can support the acceleration of renewable energy generation in Wales to maximise local economic and social value.

Closing the gap

Electricity demand in Wales has been dropping in recent years, reducing 20% from 17.6 TWh in 2005 to 14 TWh in 2021. However, as Figure 3 shows, electricity demand in Wales is expected to increase from c. 14 TWh in 2021 to c. 37 TWh in 2050 – a more than 160% increase in demand, resulting from the widespread expected electrification of heat and transport. Because electricity consumption in Wales is projected to increase so significantly, by 2050 today’s renewable electricity generation would be equivalent to just 20% of Wales’ projected electricity consumption[7].


Therefore, it is imperative that renewable deployment in Wales accelerates, in order to keep pace with the growth in electricity demand that is projected out to 2030, and beyond.


Figure 3: Welsh electricity generation and demand trends

Looking to the future

Regen has been working with the Welsh Government to gather evidence of future Welsh energy trends, to inform their consultation on updating the renewable energy targets. The consultation was published this week and raises a number of important questions, such as:

How far out to the future should new targets look?
  • 2030 is only a few years away and, if onshore and offshore wind projects experience the same development timescale as historic trends, then most of the projects that will commission before 2030 (and determine whether the 70% target is met) are already in development. The Crown Estate has stated an ambition for 4 GW of floating offshore wind in the Celtic Sea by 2035, and the Welsh Government has committed to achieve net zero emissions by 2050. Should the new targets focus on ambition beyond 2030?
How should they balance ambition and feasibility, and under what timescales?
  • Wales’ abundant renewable energy resources are technically more than sufficient to match – or exceed – future projections of electricity demand . However, illustrative projections[8] of renewable electricity projects (beyond the identified project pipeline) suggest that, in order to generate the equivalent of 100% of Welsh electricity demand from Welsh renewable electricity capacity, Wales would require (collectively):
           •  Onshore wind capacity to more than double compared to the 2021 baseline.
           •  Solar PV capacity to more than triple compared to the 2021 baseline.
           •  Offshore wind capacity to increase more than seven-fold.
How can targets stimulate renewable energy deployment while still prioritising local ownership and the retention of socio-economic value within Wales?
  • Another Welsh Government target is for at least 1 GW of renewable energy to be locally owned by 2030, with all new energy developments encouraged to have at least an element of local ownership. In this regard, Wales has achieved nearly 90% of its target – there is now 897 MW of locally owned renewable capacity, with over 40 MW of locally owned renewable energy capacity commissioned in 2021. How can such a target continue to encourage local ownership, without limiting the potential for large-scale deployment?
How much should targets focus on future electricity demand, such as encouraging the deployment of energy efficiency measures?
  • Any target centred on equivalent electricity demand is impacted by both electricity demand and generation, and all net zero CCC pathways include a reduction in energy demand of 18 to 24 TWh annually by 2050 due to efficiency savings[9]. If these reductions are not realised, then Wales’ electricity demand could be greater than that modelled, jeopardising progress towards any future targets. On the other hand, if Wales were to be proactive with the rollout of domestic retrofit and other efficiency measures, then the amount of renewable electricity generation required to meet the target would be reduced.

Why does it matter?

Having a conscious, purposeful goal increases the likelihood of success. By setting renewable energy targets the Welsh Government is stating its ambition for the future and setting a direction for the industry to follow, which drives forward progress. By committing to launch a formal consultation to review those targets, they are providing the industry with the opportunity to rise to the challenge, and put forward their own ambitions for the future of energy generation in Wales.


The consultation on reviewing energy targets is open until the 18th of April 2023. More details can be found here: https://www.gov.wales/review-wales-renewable-energy-targets


You can find the latest Energy Generation in Wales report on the Welsh Government’s website, or download it here: https://www.regen.co.uk/project/energy-generation-and-use-in-wales/

References:

1. Welsh Government, 2022; Energy Use in Wales, Second Edition. Source: www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2022-06/energy-use-wales-report.pdf

2. BEIS, 2022; Regional and local authority electricity consumption statistics. Source: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/regional-and-local-authority-electricity-consumption-statistics

3. House of Commons, Welsh Affairs Committee, 2021; Renewable energy in Wales. Source: https://committees.parliament.uk/work/833/renewable-energy-in-wales/publications/

4. GOV.UK, 2022; Renewable Energy Planning Database: quarterly extract. Source: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/renewable-energy-planning-database-monthly-extract

5. Regen 2022; Regen’s key priorities and recommendations for REMA. Source: https://www.regen.co.uk/regens-key-priorities-and-recommendations-for-rema/

6. Welsh Government, 2022; Renewable Energy Deep Dive Biannual Recommendations Update 1. Source: https://www.gov.wales/sites/default/files/pdf-versions/2022/9/3/1663774216/renewable-energy-deep-dive-biannual-recommendations-update-1.pdf

7. In the CCC’s balanced pathway. Source: https://www.theccc.org.uk/publication/sixth-carbon-budget/

8. Source: Regen analysis. National Grid ESO, FES 2022; WPD DFES, 2021; SPEN DFES, 2021; CCC 6th Carbon budget, 2019.

9. Source: CCC 6th Carbon Budget; Regen analysis.